Jillian tagged me for the Classics Book Tag – thanks, Jillian! So, let’s get on with it. Also, please enjoy this completely unrelated but extremely pretty stock photo I’ve included, mostly because I’ve pretty much tapped out Unsplash’s supply of book-related stock images.
1. An over-hyped classic you really didn’t like?
Le Mort d’Arthur. It’s basically 400+ pages of dudes in chain main slicing one another’s bodily appendages off as if they were made of butter. Pass.
The Catcher in the Rye. I hated Holden Caulfield from beginning to end, and it’s the first time in ages that I found myself rooting for a twist ending where THE MAIN CHARACTER SHOCKINGLY DIES AT THE END AND IS ACTUALLY NARRATING FROM BEYOND THE GRAVE. Although my theory is that Holden Caulfield could not be improved even by death.
2. Favourite time period to read about?
Any time period in which there are top hats.
3. Favourite fairytale?
Priče iz davnine (Croatian Tales of Long Ago) by Ivana Brlić-Mažuranić. My grandmother and mother used to read these tales to us when we were little. They are dark and awesome and in one of them a woman crosses the sea and meets a giant bee. This is trippy and amazing and should happen in all fairy tales all the time.
4. What is the most embarrassing classic you haven’t read?
Oh so many. But I’d have to say A Vindication of the Rights of Woman by Mary Wollstonecraft, because although I’ve quoted it in more than one university essay, I’ve never actually read a word of it. The same applies to the Aeneid, only I don’t feel so bad about that.
5. Top 5 classics you want to read?
- The Portrait of a Lady, by Henry James, which I am currently ‘reading’ (i.e., it’s sitting on my night-desk with a bookmark in Chapter Five since March).
- Middlemarch, by George Eliot.
- Lady Chatterley’s Lover, by D.H. Lawrence.
- Don Quixote, by Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra
- Waverley, by Walter Scott. It’s a travesty that I didn’t read this WHILE I WAS IN SCOTLAND.
I’d say Ulysses but I’d be lying.
6. Favorite modern book/series based on a classic?
To be honest, I’m a little suspicious of books that re-write classics. I feel like they sometimes end up too stilted, with the authors struggling to make nineteenth-century plot points work in the twenty-first century.
I do love a good send-up, though, and Terry Pratchett’s Discworld series is awesome; he frequently parodies famous classics: Wyrd Sisters is a send-up of Macbeth and Hamlet, for instance, and Maskerade parodies The Phantom of the Opera.
7. Favorite movie version / tv series based on a classic?
I could talk about this all day. And I already have when it comes to Jane Austen adaptations, of which there are too many to list here. I’ve also written about my favourite adaptations of books here. When it comes to classics:
- North and South (2005), based on Elizabeth Gaskell’s novel. Richard Armitage should teach a class on brooding. He does it so well.
- Jane Eyre (2006), based on the Charlotte Brontë novel. I’m a little bit more ambivalent about the 2011 movie, despite Michael Fassbender’s presence, which should be an automatic plus in the movie’s favour.
- The Great Gatsby (1974), because Robert Redford is Gatsby, and that’s really all I need to know.
- Much Ado About Nothing (1994). I have to hand it to Kenneth Branagh, this movie is adorable. And Emma Thompson is just brilliant in it.
- The Lord of the Rings (2001-2003). Lush landscapes, handsome men, and teeny-tiny dudes in hairy boots. I love this epic series.
- Rebecca (1940), based on the Daphne du Maurier novel, an early Hitchcock film and just incredible.
- Bleak House (2005) and Little Dorrit (2008), both based on Dickens novels, and both scripted by the indefatigable Andrew Davies.
- Clueless (1995), based on Austen’s Emma, Easy A (2010), based on The Scarlet Letter, and 10 Things I Hate About You (1999), based on The Taming of the Shrew, which is incredibly 90s and hilarious.
- The Musketeers (2014-2016), which is the first adaptation of The Three Musketeers I’ve seen that doesn’t make me want to roll my eyes so frequently that they’re in danger of popping right out of my skull.
8. Worst classic to movie adaptation?
- Ken Branagh’s Frankenstein. Just… urgh.
- Movies based on Dumas’ The Three Musketeers, particularly The Musketeer (2001) and The Man in the Iron Mask (1998). BizzareVictoria wrote a fantastic blow-by-blow account of this movie’s hilarious awfulness, and you should definitely read it.
9. Favorite editions you’d like to collect more of?
One day, I would love to own a copy of the Peacock edition of Pride and Prejudice. Isn’t it purrtty?
10. An underhyped classic?
It’s not so much the case now, but a few years ago nobody had ever heard of Elizabeth Gaskell’s novels, which I think is a right shame. Cranford and North and South have more traction now thanks to film adaptations, but Ruth and Wives and Daughters are also great books that are less well-known.
Let me know your answers in the comments below, or on your own blog!
28 replies on “The Classics Book Tag (AKA Oh My God I Can’t Believe I Still Haven’t Read All These Books Please Don’t Judge Me)”
Holden Caulfield is my least favourite character ever!
So many great tv and movie adaptations. I love 10 Things I Hate About You! ❤︎
Haha, yeah, I don’t think he’s much of a crowd favourite, to be honest. :D
THE PORTRAIT OF A LADY IS SO GOOD!! And I must read Middlemarch. Really, I must. I agree with you on that excellent adaptation of Much Ado! The music alone, eh! YOU MUST READ WOLLSTONECRAFT. Yes indeed to top hats.
I know, I can’t believe I haven’t read all these books yet!
Middlemarch is lovely — though the first 100 pages are a bit dry. After that it’s wonderful. Worth sticking with!
I keep hearing that! I read The Mill on the Floss years ago and found it very bleak. I’m hoping my experience with Middlemarch is better.
Wow I found myself nodding my head at pretty much all of the answers (except the bit about Terry Pratchett because I absolutely don’t.. get it.. at all.. yet). “I’d say Odyssey but I’d be lying” had me chuckling! Great post.
Thanks! That “yet” sounds promising – it took me a little bit to get into Pratchett and to get his sense of humour, but once I did I never looked back. :)
I haven’t read the Aeneid yet, either, but need to change that. But I am okay with not having read Ulysses!
Haha, yeah, Ulysses is definitely one of those classics that you don’t look forward to reading!
Much Ado is one of those movies where I have lines popping into my head at opportune moments, with the exact diction of Kenneth, Emma, et al. The delivery was just so perfect. (Except for Michael Keaton’s Dogberry, which was a bit weird.) Wyrd Sisters would also be one of my picks. And I would like to attempt Portrait of a Lady at some point, I have yet to get through any thing by Henry James longer than a novella.
Yes! The movie was just so perfect. I didn’t get Michael Keaton as Dogberry either, although I must admit he’s grown on me a little.
Oooh, I’ll have to check out the 1974 The Great Gatbsy. I was underwhelmed by the 2013 adaptation.
And I agree about top hats – you can hardly go wrong!
Yeah, the 2013 adaptation was definitely disappointing for me. It just didn’t click, which is a shame.
Yeah, Holden was a little punk. You have to see right through him.
Good luck on Quixote. I found it enjoyable and entertaining. And really if you only read the first book (b/c there are two), you will have done well.
Haha, thanks! I’m hoping I’ll tackle Don Quixote soon!
You had me nodding my head at Le Mort d’Arthur. I mean what is the big bruhahha about a bunch of people slicing each other’s head off? I mean seriously, why?? Tophats is the best time period to read period! And Sir Terry Pratchett….his brilliance will be sadly missed! I became a Pratchettian when I randomly picked up Masquerade and life would never be the same again!! Wonderful post!!
Thanks! Pratchett is usually something you come to by accident, or thanks to a recommendation, and then you’re hooked. :)
The only Pratchetts I’ve read so far are Good Omens and The Bromeliad Trilogy, both of which I loved and made me laugh out loud. I really need to read more Pratchett but lately I’m obsessed with middlebrow women’s fiction and Anthony Trollope, all of which are good reads in troubling times.
I haven’t actually read the Bromeliad! I was always obsessed with Discworld but I really want to explore more of his writing. And middlebrow women’s fiction + Anthony Trollope definitely seems like a good combination. :)
I share your preference for top hats :) I really love the movie of ‘Sense and Sensibility’ (1995), in a large part because it features Alan Rickman. However, I’m not sure how it compares to the book – while I’m a big fan of ‘Pride and Prejudice’ I never got round to ‘Sense and Sensibility’ for some reason. An oversight, I think!
Thanks! Yeah, I really like the screenplay of the movie, I think it does deviate a little from the book, but mostly it’s all good stuff, so I don’t mind. :)
Love your description of Le Mort d’Arthur :) Middlemarch is just outstanding but you have to be prepared for a slowish start while the characters establish themselves.
Haha, thanks! It seems like a lot of people are saying that Middlemarch starts really slow!
Dont give up until at least after Dorothea returns from Rome
OK, I’ll remember that. The mention of Rome is definitely enough to keep me interested, at least. :)
I’ve never seen this tag before – really interesting! :) I kind of agree about Catcher in the Rye although I have to admit that I liked Mort D’Arthur.
Also I have five different copies of Pride and Prejudice but not the Peacock edition. Maybe one day *sigh*
Haha, yes, the Peacock edition is definitely the dream, no matter how many copies of P&P you already have! :D